Art giveaways usually follow a simple formula: offer a free print or small original in exchange for something the artist wants—an email address, a social media follow, or foot traffic at an event. The goal is to build awareness, grow a list, or spark engagement by giving people a chance to win something for free.
I’ve seen both individual artists and galleries run these kinds of promotions. And over the years, I’ve observed—and occasionally participated in—these giveaways myself. What I’ve noticed has made me question their effectiveness. They may feel like a quick win, but in most cases, they generate a lot of surface activity and very little substance.
Giveaways Can Attract the Wrong Crowd
When you give away art, you tend to attract people who like free stuff—not necessarily people who are ready to buy. Yes, your email list or follower count might grow, but that growth is often inflated with names that won’t engage with future promotions or ever make a purchase.
A bloated list full of unqualified leads can actually become a liability—costing more to manage and making it harder to interpret your real engagement and performance data.
You May Be Training Your Audience to Expect Free
One of the unintended side effects of frequent giveaways is that you can condition your audience to wait. I’ve heard people say things like, “I’ll hold off and see if I win one,” or “Maybe they’ll do another giveaway soon.” That’s the opposite of what we want buyers thinking.
Over time, these promotions can diminish the perceived value of your work. If you’re offering it for free regularly, how valuable—or exclusive—can it be?
If You Try It, Track It
I’m not suggesting giveaways should be banned from your toolbox entirely. In the right setting—with a high-quality audience—they might generate useful engagement. But if you’re going to run one, track it carefully:
-
Who entered?
-
Did they stay on your list?
-
Did any of them buy something later?
-
Was the cost of the giveaway (including your time) justified?
If it doesn’t lead to sales or meaningful interaction, it’s probably not worth repeating.
Better Alternatives for List Growth
Instead of giveaways, consider building your list with value:
-
Offer early access to new collections.
-
Share behind-the-scenes content or process insights.
-
Provide exclusive previews or subscriber-only content.
These approaches may grow your list more slowly, but they tend to attract the kind of people who are genuinely interested in your work—and more likely to become collectors.
Have you tried a giveaway as part of your marketing?
What was the outcome?
Did it result in lasting engagement or sales?
I’d love to hear from those who have found success with giveaways—or who have a different take on their potential. Let me know in the comments.